Letters of Mass Construction

Science Fiction Fandom: The Pond Is Big Enough For All Of Us

I have been thinking about science fiction a lot this last week. The Hugos going boom started it (my earlier blog post goes into that ball of fun). After the Hugos went all Big Bang. Its fandom started chasing each other around with pitchforks and torches. I have been reading it all. Posting on many people’s blogs and Facebook pages. Having long conversations with people I respect and people I barely know. It has left me very sad for the field I love so much.

What I found interesting was people’s inability to stop letting the trolls dictate the conversation. There are people running around spraying gas on fires everywhere. Cackling as they scream, “burn, baby, burn.” Often they are ignored but rarely are they told to cut that shit out. We are trying to have conversation here. People’s feelings are hurt. This is important.

Our community needs to get past this and I think we will. We just have to take a step back. Take a breath and start talking to each other about why we love science fiction so damn much. I could give up a lot of things in life but I could never give up reading science fiction. It is that important to me.

I started reading it at an early age and I have been reading it ever since, well over 35 years. I read everything. I know I have certain types of books I like more. I also know that is likely to change from year to year. As a kid I liked John Carter of Mars. I recently tried to read them again. It did not end well. Then there is a book like Dune which I have lost track of how many times I have read.

I do not feel that my taste in books is superior to anyone. I like what I like. I thought Ancillary Justice by Ann Leckie was fantastic. The Buntline Special by Mike Resnick was great. The Girl With All The Gifts by Mike Carey was maybe the best zombie story I have ever read. These books had nothing in common with each other. If you look over my Goodreads list you will see nothing in common is my theme.

My first adult job was at a bookstore. I would eventually become the manager of that store as I worked my way through college. They were great years. My favorite part of that job was selling books. All kinds of different books. It forced me out of my comfort zone to be able to be a great bookseller. I had one customer who loved Conan. I can honestly say Robert Howard was not my thing. I had tried. So instead I read Robert Jordan’s Conan. I liked it more than the Howard books and it gave me a jumping off point. It then became a game for me and this customer to get him to spend all of the money he brought with him to the store. I fought dirty and enlisted any customer who was in the science fiction/fantasy section to help me take every last penny. It led to some great debates and fantastic conversations. I found myself reading books I never would have imagined reading before I took the job. I truly believe my ability to put students in books they like is directly related to those early bookstore days.

It was during that job I started going to conventions and finding a room full of people who loved what I loved. People who read books. People who were passionate and would literally stop eating to tell me about what they were reading. We were fans. This was our community. This is our community. The Hugo blow up hurts all of us but I know we are better than this. Our community will survive and I can only hope get stronger.

I will vote for the Hugos this year. I will pick the choices I think are best in their categories. I will not take the nuclear option and vote no award, unless I think there is absolutely nothing I can vote for. I encourage everyone to do the same. I encourage you to get involved. To communicate. To remember what it is we love about science fiction. To share our passion. Shout down the trolls and do what we do best. Love reading.

(Visited 452 times, 1 visits today)

8 Responses to “Science Fiction Fandom: The Pond Is Big Enough For All Of Us”

  1. This is a lovely post. Thank you.

  2. Murphy says:

    A significant portion of the community has described people like me as dinosaurs. Once labeled as such, we’re dismissed as nonentities after getting slapped with a long list of terms that end with ist, ism, and phobia.

    I think there is a schism and after years of watching, I do not think there will be any reconciliation.

    • csdaley says:

      I am interested in the significant part. I haven’t experienced this and I know a few people with a far greater reach than mine have expressed the same thing. Having said that. I don’t want to discount your feelings. Since you clearly feel this way it means that there is a problem. I truly hope you are wrong about the reconciliation. I will do my best from this moment forward to be more vocally active in keeping it respectful and inclusive. I can tell you that you are always welcome here. If our paths ever cross at a convention, Facebook, Twitter, whatever I will gladly engage in a discussion of our favorite books.

    • Draig says:

      Sounds like the usual ‘white fragility’ drivel. Why are you people so hyper-sensitive to being challenged about your bigotry? The victimhood-complexes you create are almost as elaborate (and just as fictitious) as the fiction you read.

  3. Nolly says:

    “Often they are ignored but rarely are they told to cut that shit out.”

    When people are claiming to be censored / silenced / ignored, even if there is no evidence supporting that claim, telling them to shut up or play by different conversational rules is rarely effective, unfortunately. Thus, ignoring them seems like the least-destructive option.

    • csdaley says:

      Thanks for the comment. I probably didn’t phrase that exactly right. It wasn’t so much as telling them not to talk but that we don’t accept your bad behavior. In particular when it comes to threats of any kind. I feel strongly that should be shouted down. A few people wrote very eloquently why it needed to stop. I wish more had.

Leave a Reply

This website and its content are copyright of Letters of Mass Construction  | © Letters of Mass Construction 2022. All rights reserved.

Site design by 801red